This lack of detection has nothing to do with 'sequence diversity' according to WPIs own reported sequencesMy money is on lying – but we will see.
A frequent excuse for why so many other labs cannot find XMRV via PCR is that there is 'so much sequence diversity' in XMRV, that other labs primers designed in-house cannot detect the variants in patients.
…
And here is the bigger problem: There is no sequence diversity in the WPIs reported sequences. They are all the same relative to one another, and relative to a laboratory plasmid VP62 that everyone is using as positive controls in the negative studies. This is beyond obvious to even the most casual observers:
There is no excuse for why primers directed towards VP62 would not be able to detect the very sequences the Judy Mikovits herself as uploaded into GenBank. There is no diversity. The uploaded sequences of 'XMRV from patients' are VP62.
…
The sequences of viruses found in different patients at different times from different parts of the country (world?) are virtually identical not only to one another, but a XMRV plasmid routinely used in labs.
Just to really drive home how absurd this is, here is an alignment made from the exact same region of XMRV in HIV-1, from only a small subset of HIV-1, Group M, Subtype C viruses found in different patients at different times from South Africa only:
In the WPIs liek, totally diverse sequences, there are only a handful of variations (strong majority of which are in one sequence, 1317, while others dont differ at all)-- look for the black dots. Contrast that with the HIV sequences of the same region of gag-- at almost every point, there is diversity in sequence. Think its a numbers game? Pick two HIV sequences at random-- there is more diversity between those *two* sequences than there is in the entirety of WPIs 'patient sequences' and a laboratory clone.
If someone says other labs cannot 'find' XMRV via PCR because XMRV is 'too diverse', they are lying or stupid beyond repair.
Friday, January 13, 2012
The reason why VP62 is a stupid diversion
Sorry to rehash this old stuff, but it needs to be said. Some patients go around claiming that it was not VP62 that was found by Mikovits and Lombardi et al 2009. Well, doh, it is VP62, and nothing else.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Labels
5-AZA
A. Melvin Ramsay
Acne
Advocacy
Alan Light
Alternative medicine is an untested danger
Ampligen
Andrew Wakefield
Anecdote
Anthony Komaroff
Antibiotics
Antibodies
Anxiety
Aphthous Ulcers
Apnea
Asthma
Autism
Autoimmune Disease
Behçet’s
Ben Katz
Bertrand Russell
Biology
Blood sugar
Bruce Carruthers
Caffeine
Calcium
Cancer
Capitalism
Cardiology
Carmen Scheibenbogen
CBT/GET
CDC
Celiac Disease
Cereal Grains
CFIDS
Chagas
Charité
Charles Lapp
Christopher Snell
Chronix
Clinician
Coconut Milk
Cognition
Common Sense and Confirmation Bias
Conversion Disorder
Coxiella Burnetii
Coxsackie
Criteria
Crohn's
Cushing's Syndrome
Cytokine
Daniel Peterson
Darwinism
David Bell
Depression
Diabetes
Diagnostic
Differential
Disease
Diseases of Affluence
DNA
DNA Sequencing
Dog
DSM5
EBV
EEG
Eggs
Elaine DeFreitas
Elimination Diet
Enterovirus
Epstein-Barr
ERV
Etiology
Evolution
Exercise Challenge
Faecal Transplant
Fame and Fraud and Medical Science
Fatigue
Fatty Acids
Fibromyalgia
Francis Ruscetti
Fructose
Gene Expression
Genetics
Giardia
Gordon Broderick
Gulf War Illness
Gut Microbiome
Harvey Alter
Health Care System
Hemispherx
Hemolytic Uremic Syndrome
Herpesviridae
High Blood Pressure
Historic Outbreaks
HIV
HPV
Hyperlipid
Ian Hickie
Ian Lipkin
Immune System
Infection
Intermittent Fasting
It's the environment stupid
Jacob Teitelbaum
Jamie Deckoff-Jones
Jo Nijs
John Chia
John Coffin
John Maddox
José Montoya
Judy Mikovits
Karl Popper
Kathleen Light
Kenny De Meirleir
Lactose
Lamb
Laszlo Mechtler
LCMV
Lecture
Leonard Jason
Leukemia
Life
Liver
Loren Cordain
Low Carb
Low-Dose Naltrexone (LDN)
Luc Montagnier
Lucinda Bateman
Ludicrous Notions
Lumpers and Splitters
Lyme
Mady Hornig
Mark Hasslett
Martin Lerner
Mary Schweitzer
MCS
ME/CFS
Medical Industry
Medicine is not based on anecdotes
Michael Maes
Migraine
Milk and Dairy
Mitochondria
MMR
Money and Fame and Fraud
MRI
Multiple Chemical Sensitivity
Multiple Sclerosis
Mutton
My Symptoms
n-1
Nancy Klimas
Narcolepsy
Neurodermitis
Neuroscience
NK-Cell
Nocebo
NSAID
Nutrition
Obesity
On Nutrition
Pain
Paleo
Parathyroid
Pathogen
Paul Cheney
PCR
Pharmaceutical Industry
Picornavirus
Placebo
Polio
Post Exertional Malaise
POTS/OI/NMH
PTSD
PUFA
Q Fever
Quote
Rare Disease
Research
Retrovirus
Rheumatoid Arthritis
Rituximab
RNA
Robert Gallo
Robert Lustig
Robert Silverman
Robert Suhadolnik
Rosario Trifiletti
Sarah Myhill
Sarcasm
Science
Sequencing
Seth Roberts
Shrinks vs. Medicine
Shyh-Ching Lo
Simon Wessely
Sinusitis
Sjögren's
Somnolence
Sonya Marshall-Gradisnik
Speculation
Stanislaw Burzynski
Statins
Stefan Duschek
Study
Sucrose
Sugar
Supplements
Symptoms
T1DM
T2DM
There is no such thing as Chronic Lyme
There is no such thing as HGRV
Thyroid
Tinitus
To Do
Toni Bernhard
Tourette's
Treatment
Tuberculosis
Vaccine
Video
Vincent Lombardi
Vincent Racaniello
Virus
Vitamin B
Vitamin D
VP62
When Evidence Based Medicine Isn't
Whooping Cough
Wolfgang Lutz
WPI
XMRV
You fail science forever
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments are most welcome! But please:
- No SPAM whatsoever, no supplements, no pharmaceuticals, no herbs or any other advertisements
- Absolutely no quack-doctors pushing their quack-BS websites (and if you are a quack, I will call you out)
- Be critical if you want to, but try to be coherent
Comments are moderated, because I am tired of Gerwyn-V99-The-Idiot and his moronic sockpuppets, and tired of the story of the two dogs, but I will try to publish everything else.
If you are not Gerwyn (and want to tell me something other than the story of the two dogs), then relax and write something! :-)